Critics’ opinion on the mentally disturbed narrator who has a hadith in the Two Sahihs

Abstract

The article deals with one of the aspects that hadith scholars have been concerned with, which is the issue of mental confusion among hadith narrators. The study is devoted to those who were described as having mental confusion on the two Sahihs. It will first clarify the concept of mental confusion and the interest of scholars in studying it. Next, an analysis of the position of critics regarding the hadiths of those described as mentally disturbed will be presented.

يتناول المقال أحد الجوانب التي اهتم بها علماء الحديث، وهو مسألة الاختلاط بين رواة الحديث. وقد خصصت الدراسة لمن وصفوا بالارتباك العقلي من الرواة في الصحيحين. وسنوضح أولاً مفهوم الاختلاط واهتمام العلماء بدراسته. وبعد ذلك سيتم عرض تحليل لموقف النقاد من أحاديث المختلط.